TOGETHER WE CAN

Community Based Sustainable Tele-Chronic Disease Management

A Project of Bangladesh Medical Association on North America-Louisiana Chapter (BMANA-LA).

A Collective Capacity Model of Chronic Disease Management Harnessing Technology, Trust and Power of Human Connections

  • The Story
  • Chronic Disease Management in Bangladesh
  • An Innovative Model Combining Social Networks and Remote Monitoring
  • Our Mission and Future

In a remote community in Rajshahi, Bangladesh, a small business owner named Kalam, in his late fifties has been suffering from long-standing diabetes. He has been taking health service from local diabetes center, but he received minimal blood tests, few medications, and inconsistent follow up service. His health has not improved and gradually his vision became blurry, feet started hurting, and was feeling tired more often.  He is the main bread earner of his family and was worried of what would happen to his family if he is not him. Therefore, he resorted to a relative, who is also local medical personnel, who gave him a revised prescription. He perceives that he is better than the doctors at the diabetes center. When asked to take regular blood glucose measurement, he said he will go to his next-door neighbor. His neighbor has blood glucose measurement machine and helps him in the process. However, nothing is in place to ensure routine check-up. He only checks when he is not feeling well. He Kalam’s long standing diabetes, if not well controlled, puts him in increased risk of heart attack, stroke, and kidney disease, which he does not know.

Kalam’s story is a glimpse of many people struggling with chronic diseases, such as hypertension, high cholesterol, and diabetes, in developing countries. Bangladesh is one of those countries, with limited health care access to people, particularly those living rural and remote areas. While many may think that infectious diseases comprise main health burden in Bangladesh, chronic diseases and complications of chronic diseases account for half of the morbidity and mortality in the country (please see below for further statistical data). Furthermore, due to lack proper awareness and monitoring service, many people, particularly the marginalized ones, experience stroke, heart attack, and kidney failure and face untimely death. Families struggle when loved ones die or incur paralysis from these complications, often without knowing the contributing cause.

Kalam’s story also illustrates the power of social networks to meet health care needs. Kalam resorts to his medical personnel relative to revise prescription of a doctor, and his next-door neighbor to help him monitor blood glucose. Together they support him to help him overcome his barriers to health, and support to keep him healthy. This natural practice has led us to consider following possibilities:  

What if a health care service taps into the power of collective action among residents in a community?

What if a health care service strongly considers residents barriers and promotes collective capacity to overcome them?

What if a service actively searches of trusted altruistic leaders as opposed to political interest driven leaders to help coordinate care?

What if the service employs a technology integrated with the local context to continuously monitor chronic disease states and intervenes before it is too late?

 

Our model of chronic disease management builds from understanding a community. With that understanding, it involves patients’ close social networks to help meet treatment goals, and technology to enable providers remotely monitor chronic disease status. First, we aim to conduct ethnographic description of a community to understand the community. Then, we identify close social networks of patients with known chronic disease status to facilitate collaborative actions among them to support the patients. Lastly, we involve trusted leaders endorsed by the patients to coordinate weekly insertion of chronic disease measurement data, such as blood pressure or blood glucose measurement, in a secured computer remotely accessible to providers. The measurement data is to be monitored by the providers. The providers work with the collaborative network to help meet patients’ goals.

=Collaboration among patient and social networks

= Blood pressure measurement data flow

= Provider’s remote access.

 

Figure: A Diagrammatic Representation of Our Model.

Our model recognizes that many aspects of chronic disease management, such as buying medicine, remembering to take medicine, and lifestyle changes, are primarily driven by patients. Promoting collective capacity by involving patient’s close social network can be a powerful tool help people take ownership of their own care.  Furthermore, technology can be used to remotely monitor patients’ chronic disease status regularly to provide early intervention whenever necessary.

Establishing continuous health care access across communities is our ultimate mission. We want to start in a community at a small scale to establish a model. Then, we want to replicate and expand to systematically engage with other communities to improve chronic disease status across Bangladesh and beyond. By delivering timely intervention to chronic disease problems, we believe that we will be able to help many families who may lose their loved ones early from stroke, heart attacks, and kidney failure.

Our pilot project will be implemented at Khorigapara community located at Godagari subdistrict in Rajshahi, Bangladesh addressing hypertension. Health care access is considered as one of the pressing felt need by residents living there. Please consider more data about the community, current evidence of our model, and description of our project below. You can also download our complete project here.

The needs for sustainable and continuous health care access for chronic diseases are enormous among marginalized communities. Your little help can make a establish lasting access of health care across communities.

We truly count on your generous donation!   

  • World health organization (WHO) estimates that 80% of chronic disease occurs in low- and middle-income countries1.
  • Each year 2.6 million people die from being overweight or obese; 4.4 million people die as a result of high cholesterol, and 7.1 million people die as a result of raised blood pressure1 in developing countries.
  • Many of these chronic diseases are unlikely to get cured. Therefore, prevention and controlling of the diseases has been the mainstay of treatment.
  • Bangladesh is also experiencing a shift from a disease prevalence dominated by infectious disease to more non-communicable chronic diseases, such as hypertension, diabetes, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease2.
  • In Bangladesh, chronic diseases such as heart disease, stroke, cancer, chronic respiratory diseases and diabetes account for half of the annual morbidity(47%) and mortality (54%)2. Hypertension is a known risk factor stroke, heart attack, and chronic kidney disease.

Help the Hypertension, High cholesterol Patient

  • To establish a model for chronic disease management that builds from local understanding of problems, clear understanding of local priorities, community social networks, and appreciation of local resources, capability, and leadership.
  • Recognize that many aspects of management of chronic diseases, such as, diabetes and hypertension, must be primarily driven by patients. Patients must take multiple medications, make changes in life style, and follow up with doctors regularly.
  • Increase patient’s agency and ownership to care by involving patient’s close social networks and trusted leadership and facilitating collaborative action among them.
  • Make ground works to establish a health care initiative that is authentically connected with the community and actively considers the needs and aspirations of the community.
  • Reflect the strong belief that community’s involvement and ownership must be maximized to make lasting health improvement in the community, and that sustainable changes only happen when they are primarily owned and driven by the residents of the community.

Provide a helping hand

We can’t make it alone. We need your help. Your small help can bring a big change.
  1. Necessary educational efforts will be conducted to help patients, their close social networks, and trusted leadership to understand the role of hypertension and importance to its management to prevent heart attack and stroke, known complications of hypertension.
  2. Fifteen patients will be chosen based on documented record of hypertension or detection of high blood pressure (systolic >140 mm Hg or diastolic >90 mm Hg) based on residents’ recommendation and/or house to house screening. Selected patients will be given electronic blood pressure measurement machines.
  3. Patients’ social networks will be described, and trusted leaders, defined as members in the community who are willing to work for the community and are trusted by the residents, will be identified. 
  4. Necessary educational efforts will be conducted to help patients, their close social networks, and trusted leadership to understand the role of hypertension and importance to its management to prevent heart attack and stroke, known complications of hypertension.
  5. Care will be taken so that the educational material considers community’s existing collective knowledge on hypertension and cardiovascular diseases.
  6. We will facilitate role determination and collaborative action among members of the network to identify and meet selected patients’ goals of care and remove barriers to barriers to care.
  7. Collaborating with the trusted leaders, we will facilitate collection of hypertension measurement data every week and insert data in a secured computer remotely accessible to a provider. 
  8. Providers will work with the collaborative network to meet goals of care and remove barriers. The providers will be licensed physician from Bangladesh.
  1. The primary outcome of this project will be to collect weekly blood pressure reading and make it accessible remotely consistently.
  2. Secondary outcomes will be able to meet patient’s health goals by promoting collaborative action among patient, close social network, and leaders.
  3. Other measure we will look at are patients’ satisfaction and subjective assessment of “ownership” of their care.
  4. The outcomes through this project will enable us to gather initial data on the functionality, efficiency, efficacy and initial cost of a patient-centered, community-driven, telemedicine supported chronic disease care model in a medically remote and underserved population in Bangladesh.
  5. It will give us information on effective practices in establishing this model using social networks, collected capacity, and technology that can be replicated in additional population
  6. We will document each of the outcome for individual patients, which will form the basis of necessary modification and expansion of the project.

Hope 4, a clustered randomized controlled trial conducted in Malaysia and Columbia showed a substantial reduction of blood pressure in community-based approach compared to conventional office-based approach3.

Practical applications of theories pertaining to community based participatory research approach, such as community capacity, social support, motivational interviewing has been shown to reduce blood pressure among African American residents in Hattiesburg, Mississippi, USA4.

Conducting ethnographic descriptions of the communities to document resident’s health and health care concerns and mapping out social networks to promote collaborative action enabled trusted leaders of the community and their key partners to establish a community endorsed 5-year health development plan in Nicaragua and Dominican Republic5.

Door-to-door interviewing and understanding community felt needs and resident’s preferred solutions enabled the leaders chosen by the community and key partners to implement a sustainable and community managed strategy to improve water access at a Munda community in Satkhira, Bangladesh6.

Diagram of proposal show the relationship between the independent and dependent variable. 

Community-based Participatory Health Change (CBPHC) Concept:  Felt needs*→ Ownership and Responsibility

  • Determined through hotspot discussions, interviews with identified potential participants, and members of their social networks

CBPHC Concept:  Social support to maintain patient’s health status related to hypertension.

  • Determined through interviews with identified potential participants, members of their social networks and leaders, and facilitating roles and collaborative action among them to meet patient’s goals of care.

Collection of health data to telemonitor hypertension of selected patients

  • Moderated through identified potential participants, members of their social networks, and potential leaders (see definition of leader in methodology), who will coordinate data collection

Improved health outcomes (e.g. better management of hypertension)

  • Determined by clinical data, and documentation of meeting patient’s goals of care through collaborative action among each patient, patient’s social network and leaders.

** Felt need is understood as relevance and priority of the problem as people see them7.

The following preliminary information about the community has been provided by the community informant. Further information will be collected during ethnographic research phase (see “How we want to do it” and “full proposal”)

  • Location
  • Population
  • Communication
  • Education
  • Hospital
  • Employment
  • Current Health issues
  • Khorigapara village, Godagari subdistrict, in Rajshahi district, Bangladesh.
  • The community is located at the vicinity of the padma river.
  • Situated 25 km away from Rajshahi City and 300 km away from the capital Dhaka.
  • The area is famous for tomato. Tomatoes grown by the residents of the community are exported across Bangladesh.
  • About 100 extended family. Multiple generations reside together.
  • Each family has 5-7 members
  • 500 residents approximately in total.
  • Connected by the road system which connects with Rajshahi City. Road transportation is the Primary communication system.
  • Sonamasjid river port located 40 kilometers away.
  • 1 airport at Rajshahi city located 25 km away from the community.
  • No train connection
  • One Primary School, one Aliya Madrasah, and one Degree College.
  • Most children get primary care, but the quality of education is low.
  • 1 subdistrict level hospital comprising 31 beds. However, according to community informant, residents receive minimal treatment there.
  • 1 community clinic run by medical assistants treating non-urgent acute conditions, such as common cold, and mild infection. No licensed doctor sits in the community clinic.
  • Community informant feels that that community people are deprived medically. He ranks medical need as one of the highest among the felt needs in the community along with poverty.
  • Homeopathy and traditional healers practice in the community though their impact has declined in recent years.
  • 90% people works as laborer.
  • Average income 300 taka-500 taka for labor class per day.
  • Each worker works for 20 days per month on average.
  • Multiple micro-credit non profits work in the community. However, due to ill practices of excessive and frequent loan collection, many residents have gone bankrupt.
  • Diabetes, hypertension, and hypotension have high prevalence per community informant.
  • Other diseases include stroke, paralysis, and heart disease.
  • Per community informant, there is little understanding about the role hypertension and diabetes in stroke, heart attack, and chronic kidney disease.
  • Many residents of the community with history of hypertension, and diabetes experienced sudden deaths without adequate explanation or support from local health services.
Abdullah Noor, MD
Project Lead
Abdullah Noor, MD
MD. Jubayer Ahsan, MS
Technology Lead
MD. Jubayer Ahsan, MS
Sanjida Jahan, MBBS
Patient Care Lead
Sanjida Jahan, MBBS

Advisers

 Dr. Abdul Baset Khan, MD
Adviser
 Dr. Abdul Baset Khan, MD
Brig. Gen Anwar Ibn Noor, MS, PSC.
Adviser
Brig. Gen Anwar Ibn Noor, MS, PSC.
Dr. Mohammad Mamun-ur Rahman, MBBS, Ph.D..
Adviser
Dr. Mohammad Mamun-ur Rahman, MBBS, Ph.D..
Rebecca Zaman MD (BSMMU, Bangladesh)
Adviser
Rebecca Zaman MD (BSMMU, Bangladesh)
Item Quantity/Calculation Amount (USD)
1.
Blood Pressure Monitor Cuffs
20 (5 Extra); 25 X 50 USD =
1250.00
2.
Computer System (Laptop)
2 (one back up)
650.00 X 2= 1300
3.
Internet setup and software maintenance
For one year
300 .00X 12= 3600
4.
Technician Cost
5000 taka/month X 12 months= 60000 taka
750.00
5.
International Travel Cost
1600.00
6.
Internal Transportation
550 .00
7.
Living in Rajshahi
500 USD / month X 4 months
2000.00
8.
Misc.
500.00

Total

11,000 USD

  • February 15th, 2020

    Last Date for Fundraising

  • February 15th - March 15th, 2020

    Buying blood pressure monitor; preparing for the trip.

  • March 15th - April 15th, 2020

    Conducting Ethnographic Research; selection of patients.

  • April 15th - May 15th, 2020

    Identifying social networks, trusted leadership, and assignment of roles.

  • May 15th – June 15th, 2020

    Trial blood pressure data collection and monitoring.

  • June 15th, 2020 - June 15th, 2021

    Blood pressure data collection; documenting impact of social networks and remote monitoring to meet patient care goals.

  • July 15th - December 15th, 2021

    Data analysis and preliminary report; determination of strategy for expansion.

  • January 1st - December 31st, 2022

    Expand to include care for most patients with hypertension and diabetes in Khorigapara community, Rajshahi.

  • January 1st - July 1st, 2023

    Assessment and finalization of the model; initial publication; plan for replication to other communities.

  1. Organization WH. Preventing chronic diseases: a vital investment. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization;2005.
  2. Bleich SN, Koehlmoos TLP, Rashid M, Peters DH, Anderson G. Noncommunicable chronic disease in Bangladesh: overview of existing programs and priorities going forward. Health Policy. 2011;100(2-3):282-289.
  3. Schwalm JD, McCready T, Lopez-Jaramillo P, et al. A community-based comprehensive intervention to reduce cardiovascular risk in hypertension (HOPE 4): a cluster-randomised controlled trial. Lancet (London, England). 2019;394(10205):1231-1242.
  4. Zoellner JM, Connell CC, Madson MB, et al. H.U.B city steps: methods and early findings from a community-based participatory research trial to reduce blood pressure among African Americans. The international journal of behavioral nutrition and physical activity. 2011;8:59.
  5. Aday D, Weeks J, Sherman C, Marty R, Silverstein R. Developing Conceptual and Methodological Foundations in Community Engagement. Journal of Community Engagement and Scholarship. 2015;8(1):15-24.
  6. Roy A, Marina J, Karmokar S, Islam M, Grey A, Noor A, Aday D. Applying Concepts and Methods of Community based Participatory Research and Development in Improving Water Access: A Case Report of a Munda Community in Satkhira, Bangladesh. Working Paper
  7. Bhattacharyya J. Solidarity and Agency: Rethinking Community Development. Human Organization. 1995;54(1):60-69.

Download The Proposal

An ownership model of chronic disease management harnessing technology, trust, and power of human connections.

Scroll to top